D-Rider wrote:.... and on the blue springer - it's a bouncy pogo stick - awful down bumpy, twisty B-roads.
Now I know this is the opposite to what others have said about it being "solid" - it certainly is anything but in my experience. Perhaps this depends on the weight of the rider. Maybe there is a weight where it actually works!
I think that they are a bit of a lottery, in the sense that quality control (and performance) is pretty random. In the short time I had the shock fitted to the bike, I was trying to figure out what was wrong with it. I couldn't actually figure out whether it was under or over-damped, or whether the spring rate was too hard or too soft. The only thing I was certain of was that I needed to get shot of it, and pronto...
I had a similar experience, 20 years ago, on an 851 Ducati Biposto I owned for a year or so. That had Marzocchi suspension front and rear. The front fork felt like you were riding a road drill, whereas the rear suspension every so often just tried to kill me. Hit a bump in the middle of a bend and all bets were off. I fitted a Spax rear shock and that sorted the rear end, and gradually got the front under control as well.
Just before I chopped the 851 in for the 888 SP3 (glutton for punishment) I had the Marzocchi shock serviced, as I wanted to re-fit it and retain the Spax. The guy who serviced it asked me what it was like to ride. 'Frightening' was my response. I'm not surprised he said, there was virtually no oil or gas in the shock. And this was a brand new bike...